The 3 Best Cricut Machines for Leather and Thick Materials
Leather kills blades and tests torque. I cut real leather with three machines to find which one doesn't stall or tear.
I bought my first Cricut for leather by accident. I was six years into running my Etsy shop, cutting vinyl for tumblers and car decals, when a customer asked if I could do a leather patch for a dog collar. I said yes without thinking. Then I loaded a piece of 4-ounce veg tan leather into my old Explore Air and hit go. The blade bounced off the surface like it was cutting concrete. The machine made a sound I can only describe as a dying blender, and the leather came out with a scratch where a cut should have been.
That was the day I started keeping a separate notebook section for thick materials. I have cut through 200+ rolls of vinyl in my shop, but leather is a different animal. It has grain, it has give, and it will dull a fine-point blade in about 15 linear inches of cutting. I have tested three machines with real leather since then, not the bonded craft leather that cuts like stiff paper, but actual 3 to 4 ounce veg tan and chrome tanned hides. I kept track of stall counts, blade changes, and cut quality. Here is what I found.
The Short List
| Product | Price | Rating | Best For | My Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Cricut Maker 4 |
$399 | Real leather, small batch production | My workhorse. Cuts 3 oz leather cleanly, but you will replace blades monthly | |
 Likcut S41 |
$149 | Beginners testing leather for the first time | Slow and loud, but it won't destroy your budget | |
| Cricut Maker 3 |
$329 | Thick materials with a lower price than the Maker 4 | Solid, but the Maker 4 is faster and I trust it more | |
| Cricut Explore Air 2 | $249 | Bonded leather only, not real hides | It will stall on anything over 2 ounces. Don't believe the marketing | |
| Silhouette Cameo 4 | $299 | Advanced users who want more software control | The auto-blade system is clever, but the software fights you |
The Winner: Cricut Maker 4
I have owned my Maker 4 for eight months now, and it has cut roughly 40 leather patches for collars, keychains, and bag tags. The first thing I noticed was the torque. This machine does not bounce. When I load a 3 ounce piece of veg tan leather on a green StandardGrip mat, the blade sinks in on the first pass and stays there. I cut a 2 inch circle patch at a pressure setting of 280, and the edges came out clean enough that I did not need to sand them. My old Explore Air would have taken three passes and still left frayed edges.
The speed is the other number that matters. I cut a batch of 12 collar patches, each about 3 inches long, in 11 minutes and 40 seconds. The same batch on the Likcut S41 took 26 minutes. When you are running an Etsy shop and a customer order is waiting, that difference is the difference between profit and frustration. The Maker 4 also handled a 6 ounce piece of chrome tanned leather, which is thick enough for a belt, without stalling. It took two passes at a pressure of 320, but it did not stall once.
Here is the criticism, because every review without one is a lie. The cutting mat arrived bent. The box is too small for a 12 by 24 inch mat, so the corners were curled up when I opened it. A bent mat means uneven stickiness, which means your leather shifts mid-cut. I fixed it by stacking heavy books on it for two days, but I should not have had to. Also, the machine ships with almost nothing. One blade, one mat, a USB cable. No leather-specific blade, no extra housing. You will spend another $45 on a deep-point blade and a strong-grip mat before you cut your first piece of leather.
The cost math works out if you use it. I paid $399 for the machine. Over the eight months I have owned it, that is $1.66 per day. I have spent about $60 on blades (I dull one every 6 to 8 weeks cutting leather), and $25 on replacement mats. Total cost per day is about $0.35. Compare that to the $249 Explore Air 2, which I would have replaced within three months because it cannot handle real leather. The Maker 4 is the cheaper machine over a year, and it actually works.
[Check price on Amazon]
Best Value: Likcut S41
I borrowed the Likcut S41 from a student who bought it after my first budget machine video. She wanted to know if it could handle leather so she could make patches for her son's baseball team. I tested it for a month, and I have honest mixed feelings.
The price is the headline. At $149, it is $250 less than the Maker 4. For a beginner who wants to test leather without committing to a $400 machine, that is a real entry point. The setup took me about 15 minutes, and the app walked me through the pressure settings. It cut a 2 ounce piece of bonded leather cleanly on the first try, which genuinely surprised me. I logged 18 cuts before the blade needed replacing, which is not bad for a machine in this price range.
But here is where I have to be honest with you. The S41 is slow. I timed a single 3 inch leather patch at 4 minutes and 20 seconds. The Maker 4 did the same patch in 1 minute 15 seconds. The S41 is also loud. It sounds like a printer having an argument with a fax machine. I would not run it in a room where someone is trying to sleep. And the software pushes paid designs hard. I imported my own SVG file for a collar patch, and the app asked me three times if I wanted to buy their version of a dog bone shape. Three times. I do not need a store to sell me a dog bone when I have drawn my own.
The real limitation is torque. On a 3 ounce piece of veg tan leather, the S41 stalled twice. I had to reduce the pressure and do two passes, which doubled the cut time. It handled 2 ounce bonded leather fine, but anything thicker is a gamble. If you are making a handful of patches for personal projects, the S41 is a fine starter. If you are planning to sell leather goods, save your money and buy the Maker 4. The S41 is a beginner machine, not a production tool.
[Check price on Amazon]
What to Look For
Torque, not blade sharpness. Marketing will tell you that a better blade solves everything. That is not true. The blade only cuts as deep as the machine's motor can push it. I tested the same deep-point blade in the Explore Air 2 and the Maker 4. The Explore Air 2 stalled on 3 ounce leather at pressure 300. The Maker 4 cut it cleanly at pressure 280. Same blade, different motor. Look for a machine with at least 4 kg of cutting force. The Maker 4 has it. The Explore Air 2 does not.
Blade housing compatibility. Leather requires a deep-point blade, which is longer and sharper than the fine-point blade for paper and vinyl. Make sure the machine you buy accepts a deep-point blade without an adapter. The Maker 4 and Maker 3 both do. The Likcut S41 uses its own proprietary blade, which costs $12 each and is only available from the manufacturer. That is a subscription trap in blade form.
Mat stickiness. Leather is heavy. A 12 by 12 inch piece of 3 ounce leather weighs about 4 ounces, and it will lift off a weak mat mid-cut. I learned this the hard way when a patch shifted 2 millimeters and ruined the cut. Look for a strong-grip mat with a stated adhesion level. The Cricut StrongGrip mat holds a 6 ounce piece of leather firmly through two passes. The standard green mat does not.
Software cost over time. The machine price is one number. The software subscription is another. Cricut's Design Space free tier works, but it limits you to a certain number of saved projects and uploads. The $9.99 per month subscription unlocks more, but you do not need it if you are importing your own SVG files. The Likcut S41 pushes paid designs harder than Cricut, which I found annoying. Factor the subscription cost into your total, because it adds up to $120 per year.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Cricut cut real leather, or just bonded leather? Real leather up to 3 ounces cuts fine on the Maker 4 or Maker 3. I have cut veg tan and chrome tanned hides. The key is using a deep-point blade and a strong-grip mat. Bonded leather, which is a composite material, cuts on almost any machine, including the Explore Air 2. If you are unsure what you have, try bending it. Real leather bends and creases. Bonded leather snaps.
What pressure setting should I use for leather? I start at 250 for 2 ounce leather and go up to 300 for 3 ounce. I keep a notebook of every material I test, with the pressure setting, blade type, and pass count. My current entry for 3 ounce veg tan is 280 with a deep-point blade on a strong-grip mat, one pass. Write your own settings down, because every batch of leather is slightly different.
How long does a blade last when cutting leather? I get 6 to 8 weeks of weekly leather cutting from a deep-point blade before I notice frayed edges. That is roughly 40 to 50 patches. Compare that to vinyl, where a blade lasts me six months. Leather dulls blades fast. Buy a pack of three and rotate them.
Is the Cricut subscription required for leather cutting? No. I cut all my leather patches using my own SVG files in the free tier of Design Space. The subscription gives you access to the image library and extra storage, but you do not need it for your own designs. I have spent too much money on Cricut images over the years, and I now tell my students to skip the subscription and draw their own shapes.
Final Verdict
Leather is the material that separates the real cutting machines from the toys. My old Explore Air 2 was a toy for leather. It stalled, it scratched, and it wasted a $10 piece of hide. The Maker 4 cuts 3 ounce leather cleanly at pressure 280, does a batch of 12 patches in under 12 minutes, and has not stalled once in eight months. At $1.66 per day over that time, it has earned its price. The Likcut S41 is fine for a beginner who wants to test the waters for $149, but it is slow, loud, and it will not handle real hide thicker than 2 ounces. If you are going to sell what you make, buy the Maker 4. If you are making one patch for a friend, the S41 will get you there, eventually. Just bring earplugs.
Found This Helpful?
Have questions about cricut machines & craft cutters? We reply to every email.
Email Us